BBS DOCUMENTARY PRODUCTION: THE MUSIC
|
The idea of having to create the musical soundtrack for not just one but eight
separate episodes of a documentary, fit them into themes and footage, and also
be able to afford it all was one of the more daunting obstacles I thought I
would have to face. As it turned out, it wasn't that bad; sometimes I didn't
use much music at all, while other times I flooded the audio track with it. And
ultimately, I used about 60 different pieces of music from a wide spectrum of
artists.
The secret sauce, of course, was Creative Commons
music, which gave me a wide variety
of musical types and styles to try out against the footage, without worrying about
licensing fees, rights, festival clearances, and a lot of the other baggage that can
accompany going down the road of "buying" music.
Part of the license let me remix, match, and combine pieces of music as I saw
fit, and as a result, some of the songs below sound very different in the final
soundtrack. I rarely used voices (cutting around them) and in a few cases, I
would take a 10 or 20-second piece of a song and loop and modify it to turn it
into a 2 or 3 minute background song. In fact, to be absolutely sure I was crediting
all artists I used, I went back to the actual saved video editing files and pulled
out the references to the exact MP3 and OGG files. So they're all in there, and
present and accounted for.
|
BAUD
|
|
Two artists dominate throughout all of the documentary. Paul Slocum, called "Treewave",
and Russell Purdy, known as "Sleepy Rabbit" and "Lusuido". These two bands created
songs that I thought captured perfectly what I was going for in terms of tone. Treewave
creates very warm-sounding songs using 8-bit computer equipment (including a really
cool dot-matrix printer that has a hacked ROM) while Sleepy Rabbit very simply casts
musical shadows over long, sad songs that harken to a different place.
For BAUD, I ended up using a mere two songs by Treewave, both basically variations
of the same musical phrase, done by the printer. I cut into them at a few points in
the episode to bridge between sequences, or to go under title cards. I intentionally
gave the first episode a sparse soundtrack, simply because I wanted the history to
speak for itself, and not have it feel like I had to jazz it in any way.
Probably the most jarring aspect of the Morning Coffee Hymn is that you get to hear
the singing of the other half of Treewave, Lauren Gray. Her vocals are also haunting
and distant, but like I indicated in the introduction, I avoided putting vocals into
the soundtrack because my documentary is so dependent on people talking. That doesn't
mean she's not worth listening to; she definitely is. I should also note that in fact
Treewave's music is not licensed Creative Commons, like most of the rest of the music.
I pay him a royalty for every copy of the DVD set that's sold. None of the other artists
have this deal, and it's because his theme song is so prevalent everywhere, and because
I wanted this particular artist to see funds, and also his limitations on the use of the
music were so refreshingly few, I also wanted him rewarded.
|
|
SYSOPS AND USERS
|
|
SYSOPS AND USERS has but one song, again by Treewave. Called "May Banners", it's a
complicated, layered, and beautiful piece of work, getting immediate attention with
its odd opening, and continued shifts throughout the song. I use it over the opening
and closing credits, and again Lauren Gray is screwed out of making an appearance
in the documentary.
The vast majority of SYSOPS AND USERS are intensely (and I do mean intensely) intercut
interviews, sometimes with just a word or two from each person coming together to form
ideas and concepts. Dozens of people are in this episode, and so I thought that adding
music would be distracting, since the conversation (intentionally) jumps around like a
message board, with so many different voices, you spend a lot of time keeping your
ear tuned to the changing words, and the last thing you need to be doing is pulling
voices out of music as well. I wavered every once in a while during editing (maybe I
need a song here, maybe I should cut away to a sequence with music) but I stayed firm
and kept it quiet except for the credits.
|
|
MAKE IT PAY
|
|
Intentionally, and ironically, the MAKE IT PAY episode is the most "commercial" looking of
all the episodes. It goes into the story of the BBS Industry, the characters behind it,
and the conflicts between the hobbyists and the business-makers. There was a real tension
there and I tried to capture some of that, without it descending into a cesspool of un-backed
accusations and declarations like some documentaries will do. A book would be better suited
for discussing intrigue, backstabbing and politics; I do not think I will be the one writing
such a book.
Copacetix' song "Tonya" ended up being "Jack Rickard's Theme". It just seemed to
work as a piece with his story and people discussing his personality. Luke Palmer's piano
pieces were a lifesaver in this and FIDONET for getting across a nice sense of class to
some of the sequences; I use two movements (Adagio and Rubato) of his Piano Sonata Number
2. Sleepy Rabbit, as I indicated above, brings in a few songs of sadness and thinking that
I ended up using during discussions of discontent and the like.
The bend of the music is somewhat acoustic, with a little sense of electronica that I hope
doesn't overpower what's being said.
By far my favorite piece I used for this episode was Curt Cloninger's "Post Righteousness",
which is part of a musical project he created where he took revivalist recordings and
put them to music. I don't use the revivalist recording parts, but his soundtracks to
them are a nice mix of tribal drum beating and a coffee-house jam. It really worked for me.
|
|
FIDONET
|
|
Throughout most of the production, I had a mailing list of friends and respected figures who
could give me input and advice instead of living within my own head. This enabled me to make
some decisions that saved me time and money, while making others that added quality and
variety.
After the release of my first trailer, one of my advisors said "I hope you're just not going
to fall into using techno music for all of the episodes." I hadn't given it much thought either
way (editing was still in the preliminary stage) but after he got me thinking about it, I
decided he was very right. So, the FIDONET is primarily acoustic guitar music.
This was fun and challenging, and ultimately worth the effort. But in the case of the music
I used, it tended to have people singing (since most single-guitar songs tend to have a person
who's trying to get a message across, so they sing along). Hence, I had to cut around them.
And therefore, the songs below, in some cases, are very nearly unrecognizable in their form
on the episode. In some cases, three different songs were blended together to create one.
The song "Amelio" by Copacetix really sets the tone for the work; it's the one that plays
the first time you see Tom Jennings. It was the first one I edited in, and I thought "wow,
that really does change the tone". And I really liked the tone.
Kid Cholera's "Ambien" is the opening and closing credits music (in greatly re-arranged form)
and also does a great job. It shows up halfway as well, and I don't think the documentary
showcases what a neat piece of music it is.
|
|
ARTSCENE
|
|
For all the discussion and choices to go with acoustic pieces on Fidonet, I decided that
techno and "chip music" was the way to go for the music in ARTSCENE. I used a number of
artists to punctuate certain sequences, although of course I fell back on Sleepy Rabbit
as the workhouse for a lot of the film. A lot of people who release music for the sake
of it tend to go into a certain "feel" through a lot of the pieces, and Sleepy Rabbit jumps
around a lot, giving me a lot of flexibility to fit it into scenes.
"Chip Music", by the way, is a genre of computer music that goes out of its way to
use pure sine waves and "computer" sounds, so that it has a very retro feel. (Although
the artists are so good in many cases that you can't even tell.)
Snoopdroop's piece "You're a Hero on Level Zero" shows up during the definition of "PD Scene",
and is unique among all the songs in the documentary, being created entirely on a Nintendo
Gameboy.
|
|
HPAC
|
|
Even though it might be expect that there would be electronica and techno
all over an episode that's ostensibly about "hacking", in actual fact it
goes all over the place.
This is one of the last episodes I'd edited, and by then I'd learned that
you didn't need music in "theme" to match it against the visual images
and what was being talked about. In fact, sometimes the contrast between
someone talking really quickly about something funny while combining it
with a slow dirge gives the whole thing a neat sense of weight. This happened
a lot in this episode.
One sequence I really enjoyed putting together was "Morality", and I use the
same song from Catalpa Catalpa, "Mummy", which appears in "Make it Pay", but
where in the other it's an underpinning for people talking with pride about
the BBS industry, here it's people talking about Morality, while this song
slowly builds up, menancingly, until it nearly drowns them out.
The star of the soundtrack for this episode is far and away "Oak Arena" by
Catalpa Catalpa; it's a dreamy, drifting song of which I can only use
some parts because so much of it has the sound of seems to be a restaurant
going on in the background. But the other parts of it are fantastic, and
it shows up in at least three parts, including the credit sequence.
I paid a flat fee for the usage of "Spreadsheet" by Upbeat Depression, and
I ended up using only a little of it (for the opening title sequence). That'll
show me to "invest" months and months before I start editing. What I liked
about it was the use of a dot matrix printer as the melody for a good portion
of it, and so that got in.
|
|
NO CARRIER
|
|
The final episode with music. "Compression" has no music whatsoever; I tried a little
and it felt really horrible and cheap, so I left it with just its (powerful) words. In the
case of NO CARRIER, there's probably a little sense of chintz with it, but I thought that
completely avoiding music would be silly in its own right.
Here we see the full power of Sleepy Rabbit; the episode has 11 of his songs, including 7
of them under his other name, "Lusiudo". I don't entirely hear a difference between
the two names he uses; they're both great to me. So I layer and attach the music to
various scenes, with sweeping sad chords and distant noise over the people talking about
the BBS's dial-up era fading to a close.
People looking for one song that represents the feel of this episode need look no further
than "Sell Out", the title of which isn't meaningful for this subject matter, but the
tone of which captures the sense of something gone but not forgotten with perfection.
Again, it's not likely people would think all the music in this episode was made by one
person, and especially one who didn't see one frame of footage, but that's very much the case
here.
|
|
FINAL THOUGHTS
|
|
There are many different ways to edit in background music into a film; obviously a more
artistic work that works as a single piece tends to have custom, distinct music added to
it over time, or where there is a lot of collaboration. In my case, my films stood as
music-free until nearly the end of editing, because I didn't want to use music as a crutch
to get around problems inherent in the work. I wanted these episodes to be as watchable as
possible without adding some catchy song to make it tolerable. Once I did add them, it was
initially very jarring to hear the works with music, which is why some have almost none.
I tried, with SYSOPS AND USERS, for example, to add a background throughout the episode but
thought it just confused things. And as I said above, COMPRESSION was fine with no frills
whatsoever.
At no time did I ever consider using "commercial" music for these episodes. (I did enter
negotiations for a song to play over the menu, but predictably those fell through after
about a year.) Instead, I always knew I wanted unusual and unknown groups to work with,
so I wasn't "feeding" off the fame of the song. I never liked doing that, and don't
expect I ever will in future works.
I should also mention, as I do on the DVD, that a vast majority of these artists were
found on a website called OPSOUND, which is the Open Sound Pool. They have gone out of
their way to make it easy to find musicians who are licensing their art under Creative
Commons Attribute-Sharealike, and so a vast majority of my work was done for me. Except,
of course, listening to every piece to see if I could use it, and that's pretty good
work if you can get it.
If you like the work these artists have done, communicate with them, download their other
works, and enjoy their contributions to the world.
| | |